Larisa Oleynik wins the award for being the most-often forgotten 90s crush of my overly-hormone driven childhood. Has Jennifer Love Hewitt ever thrown lightning bolts? Does Sandra Bullock ever have any kinds of skills in her films, even the most basic talents - like levitation? At the very best, Sarah Michelle Gellar would occasionally roundhouse vampires in the face.
The point being, Alex Mack and her knit beanie were underrated. Give that woman more acting jobs, preferably ones where she can turn into a puddle of semi-sentient goo with wildly inconsistent properties.
(Yes, I know what a poodle is.)